Pure water is a basic human necessity, whether for drinking or washing purposes. People usually assume that the water coming from the tap is clean. However, this water contains various contaminants and minerals, which can pose serious health risks. Therefore, water treatment is necessary to make it clean and pure. Water softener vs ro are two popular water treatment options, but most homeowners find it difficult to choose one.
This blog aims to clear this confusion by describing the difference between RO and water softener, highlighting their key uses and benefits, and helping you choose one that best meets your needs.
Basics of Water Softeners and RO Systems
Water softeners are the most common equipment used to make hard water soft. They soften the hard water by a process called ‘’Ion exchange’’. This process consists of an exchange medium that removes minerals from water and adds sodium ions. The exchange medium has synthetic resin beads, which are coated with sodium ions. When the water passes through the resin beads, sodium ions replace minerals like calcium and magnesium from it.
In an RO system, water initially passes through a filter. This filters out the chlorine and other sediments from it. After this, the water is forced through a semi-permeable membrane. The pressure causes water molecules and ionic elements pass the filter membrane easily. However, many dissolved impurities like microorganisms, inorganic salts and organic matter cannot cross the filter membrane barrier. In this way, water becomes clean and pure for drinking and cooking.
Let's have a detailed look at their differences to decide which is better reverse osmosis or water softener.
Key Differences Between Water Softeners VS RO
Choosing between a water softener vs ro system can be quite challenging. Both systems basically serve to clean the impure water but use different techniques. Therefore, we need to understand what is the difference between water softener and ro system. The final selection comes down to one’s specific needs. Before making a decision, you need to consider the following factors:
1. Purpose: Softens Hard Water Minerals vs. Purifies All Contaminants.
The main purpose of water softeners is to treat hard water, which contains high amounts of calcium and magnesium. These minerals make water hard and unsuitable for household purposes. Hard water can cause limescale build-up in pipes and home appliances, decrease soap lather, and degrade the quality of water.
In contrast, RO systems specifically focus on removing a wide range of contaminants, including microorganisms and chemicals. This makes water safe, clean, and free from potentially harmful substances, making it ideal for consumption.
2. Filtration: Ion Exchange vs. Semi-Permeable Membrane Filtration.
Both water softener vs reverse osmosis systems use different filtration methods. Water softeners operate through an ion exchange method. This method involves replacing harmful minerals with sodium ions. This exchange of ions removes the hardness of water and makes it suitable for household use.
On the other hand, an RO system uses a pre-filter and semi-permeable membrane. This membrane acts as a barrier for dissolved water contents. It allows water molecules to pass through it but blocks large particles like heavy metals and dissolved salts. In this way, it filters all the impurities of water, making it safe and pure for consumption.
3. Focus: Removes Calcium & Magnesium vs. Removes Impurities and Chemicals.
The main focus of water softeners is to remove the calcium and magnesium ions from the water. These two substances add to the hardness of water. Water softeners replace these minerals with sodium ions, which make hard water soft. However, these filters do not eliminate other contaminants like heavy metals and chlorine from water. This means the water will still contain some impurities.
In contrast, an RO system focuses on removing a wide range of contaminants from water. These include nitrates, lead, chlorine, and other chemicals which water softeners cannot remove. Removing such impurities also improves the taste of water. This makes RO systems a good option for those who prioritize the purity and quality of their drinking water.
4. Water Quality: Softens Water for Appliances vs. Provides Purified Drinking Water.
Both water softener vs ro systems enhance the quality of water, but in different ways. Water softeners improve water quality by removing its hardness. This makes water soft and suitable for a variety of household purposes. It will be easier on appliances and not lead to limescale build-up. This helps prevent appliance damage and costly repairs. Moreover, it also improves soap lather and removes hard water stains from clothes more efficiently.
On the other hand, reverse osmosis systems improve the quality of water by filtering out all the potentially harmful chemicals and substances. Moreover, RO systems can also soften the hard water. This makes water ideal for drinking and cooking purposes. This is very beneficial for the health of kids, elderly people, and immunocompromised patients.
5. Maintenance: Regular Salt Replenishment vs. Periodic Filter Replacement.
Maintenance of a water softener vs ro differs greatly. If you have a water softener, you need to check it monthly, especially the brine tank. You will have to refill salt every six to eight weeks to keep it working well. Moreover, salt bridges or clumps can form. If you notice one forming, break it up.
A reverse osmosis system needs periodic filter changes (at most every six to twelve months). Moreover, the reverse osmosis membrane needs replacement after two to five years.
Which is Better: Water Softener or Reverse Osmosis?
If you feel confused about which is better, reverse osmosis or water softener, you need to understand your requirements and identify your issues. Consider the following factors to help you decide which system is better suited for your needs:
1. Solving Hard Water Issues for the Whole House: Choose Water Softener.
If your primary concern is water hardness, you should go for a water softener. Hard water has high levels of calcium and magnesium. This can lead to limescale build-up in pipes, reduce the efficiency of household appliances, reduce soap lather, and make it hard to remove stains from clothes. A water softener removes these minerals completely, making the water soft. This resolves all the hard water issues and makes household chores easier and better.
2. Removing a Wide Range of Contaminants From Drinking Water: Opt for RO System.
If you prioritize your health and take the safety and purity of water more seriously, an RO system is a better option. RO systems excel at removing a wide range of harmful substances that can not be removed through water softeners. Their filter membranes have a pore size of 0.0001 microns, which does not allow the viruses (0.02-0.4 microns in diameter) and bacteria (0.4-1 microns in diameter) to penetrate. It also improves the taste and odor of water, making it suitable for drinking and cooking.
3. Reducing Scale Buildup in Pipes and Appliances: Go With a Water Softener.
If you have limescale build-up issues in pipes and appliances, a water softener is the way to go. Water softeners effectively prevent scale build-up by exchanging the hard minerals with sodium ions. This extends the efficiency and lifespan of household appliances like dishwashers. You won’t need to spend a lot on costly repairs or replace the appliances frequently.
4. Higher Purification and Cleaner Taste: Select Reverse Osmosis.
If you want to improve the taste of drinking water and enhance its quality, a reverse osmosis system is better suited for you. An RO filter can filter out all the impurities and heavy metals like chlorine, which alter the taste of water. Removing these contaminants will not only make it taste better but also enhance its quality, making it safe for your health.
5. Combination Systems for Comprehensive Treatment: Consider Both if Needed.
In some cases, you can go for a combination of water softener vs reverse osmosis to get a comprehensive water treatment. This will maximize the benefits of both systems. A water softener will remove the hardness of water, and a reverse osmosis system will remove the additional contaminants and improve the taste of water. Moreover, the pre-treated water from a water softener will increase the lifespan of RO filters. This will save the cost of repairing or changing filters frequently.
FAQs on Water Softener vs RO System
Here are some common questions related to the difference between ro and water softener that can arise in your mind:
1. Can a water softener purify drinking water?
Yes, water softeners can purify drinking water. However, they are mainly designed to treat the hardness of water by replacing calcium and magnesium ions with sodium ions, so some other impurities would still be present.
2. Is reverse osmosis necessary if I have a water softener?
Yes, reverse osmosis is necessary even if you have a water softener. This is because water softeners only remove the hardness of water but do not eliminate harmful contaminants like heavy metals and pathogens, which can only be removed through RO systems.
3. Can I install a water softener and RO system together?
Yes, both water softener vs ro can be installed together. Having a water softener will enhance the working of the reverse osmosis system, improving the overall quality of water.
If you are curious about whether the water filter goes before or after the softener, you can get a detailed answer here.
Conclusion
This article answers the question ‘what is the difference between water softener and ro system’ in detail, highlighting their functioning and benefits. In some cases, both systems can be used together to get a comprehensive water treatment. The combination of water softener vs ro systems helps increase the lifespan of RO filter membranes and enhances the overall quality of water by making it pure, clean, and safe.
You can explore our range of RO systems to get a filtration system that best fits your requirements. SimPure RO systems are available in countertop and under-sink options. These models come in tank and tankless configurations. You can get them for residential or commercial uses depending on your specific needs.
Explore SimPure RO Systems!
